NSPIRE Wire is independent and not affiliated with HUD.
NORFOLK, Va. - The Norfolk Redevelopment and Housing Authority says it cannot afford to renovate the roughly 200 vacant units sitting empty in its aging public housing communities, a shortfall that is costing the agency rent revenue now and threatening its federal funding next year, WHRO reported November 9.
The authority's overall occupancy rate has fallen to 87.7 percent, far below the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development's 96 percent target, and is flagged in red on HUD's public housing dashboard. Because the federal operating subsidy formula counts occupied units month by month over a 12-month period, every apartment that sits empty through the year directly shrinks the money NRHA can expect in its next fiscal year.
To reach HUD's target lease percentage, the authority would need to fill 163 more units, according to the dashboard. It does not have the money to make most of them rentable.
The vacancies are concentrated in Young Terrace, a community of 746 barracks-style brick units built in 1953, where nearly 200 apartments are empty. Roughly 270 units are vacant across NRHA's properties overall, according to a chart supplied to the authority's board in October.
The math of bringing them back is stark. NRHA's deputy executive director and chief development officer, Steve Morales, told a joint meeting of the Mayor's Housing Commission and the St. Paul Advisory Committee in October that modernizing a single unit costs the authority between $50,000 and $85,000. Repairing just half of the vacant units in Young Terrace would cost between $7 million and $8 million, he said, money the authority does not have.
In April, the NRHA board authorized up to $5 million to repair and renovate Young Terrace. Interim executive director Michael Clark has told commissioners the authority is doing better, noting that 11 new maintenance contracts have been issued. But officials have acknowledged at public meetings that making the units habitable will take more funding than NRHA can assemble.
The current crisis cannot be separated from the authority's leadership collapse a year ago. In November 2025, the NRHA board fired then-executive director Nathan Simms after members learned he had issued at least $4.3 million in no-bid contracts during a tenure of less than two years. Board members said they had been kept in the dark about the contracts and about the authority's deteriorating maintenance capacity.
At the NRHA board meeting in November 2025, Simms had been touting progress on exactly this problem, telling members the authority had completed 86 unit turn and refresh activities, 47 at Grandy Village and 39 at Young Terrace, at an average cost of around $6,000 per unit. Thirty minutes later, the board voted him out over the no-bid contracts. The gap between the $6,000 turns he was celebrating and the $50,000 to $85,000 full modernization cost the authority now cites is the gap between a cosmetic refresh and a unit that will actually hold up.
Some of those no-bid awards, totaling up to $2 million over two years, went to contractors hired to repair and renovate public housing apartments that were already long past their intended lifespan. Documents obtained by WHRO through a public records request show the companies were paid invoices of about $6,000 to $7,000 to turn individual units, a fraction of the $50,000 to $85,000 the authority now says a real modernization costs. It is not clear that the cheaper repairs were adequate, or in some cases completed at all.
At the same time, Simms was dismantling the authority's in-house maintenance operation. He fired or laid off 22 workers in 2025; the year before, the authority had let go of just one. A week before Simms was fired, pipes burst when the authority turned on the boiler serving the 310 units at Calvert Square, leaving residents without heat for weeks as temperatures dropped. One commissioner said at a December meeting that she was only then hearing about the October failure.
While hundreds of units sit empty, residents in occupied ones describe chronic hazards. WHRO's November 6 report detailed the experience of Corinne Hicks, a Young Terrace resident who moved with her two children into a hotel over the summer after years of mold, leaks, and plumbing failures in her apartment. A mold test kit she bought in March came back positive in her kitchen and bathroom; in May, she said, her doctor ran a blood test for mold that also came back positive.
Her account tracks a pattern residents and their advocates describe across the community: repairs that cover symptoms rather than causes. Maintenance workers replaced mold-infested bathroom tile and swapped out moldy upper kitchen cabinets, but stains returned. A contractor repaired her leaking kitchen sink and told her the unit needed major plumbing work; the open pipe beneath was covered with tape. When she recently opened the newly installed cabinets, the wall behind them was dark with mold again.
Another resident, Latora Trent, has filed more than 60 work orders for her Young Terrace apartment over three and a half years. Melissa Bonfiglio, a Legal Aid Society of Eastern Virginia lawyer who represents several tenants, said negligent repairs expose the authority to personal injury liability, which could cost NRHA even more of the money it says it does not have.
The human cost sits with families like Hicks's. The authority provides Walmart gift cards for food, but her hotel room has no kitchen. She lost her remote job for a phone center and says she cannot take a new one because the hotel's Wi-Fi is not secure. Her car broke down over the summer and she cannot afford repairs. With Halloween past, the family was still waiting for a clean, renovated unit to open up, the same inventory problem that has 200 apartments sitting boarded up across the community.
Residents and their advocates say the pattern has continued in the year since Simms was fired: repairs completed poorly or not at all, and conditions that return within months. The Legal Aid Society of Eastern Virginia has raised the issue repeatedly at board meetings.
The specific conditions described in Norfolk, mold growth, leaking and burst pipes, sewage backups, and heating failures, are the same categories HUD's NSPIRE physical inspection standards treat as among the most serious deficiencies in federally assisted housing. Mold-like substances and inoperative heating in cold weather are the kinds of findings that drive the lowest inspection scores and trigger the fastest correction timelines under the standards.
For an authority already flagged in red on HUD's dashboard, the inspection dimension compounds the funding one. Persistently poor physical conditions can bring heightened federal oversight on top of a shrinking operating subsidy, narrowing the authority's options further.
Susan Popkin, an Urban Institute fellow who has studied public housing for decades, told WHRO the authority faces a cascading set of problems. The logic is circular and brutal: NRHA lacks the money to renovate vacant units, the empty units generate no rent, the low occupancy cuts next year's federal subsidy, and the smaller subsidy leaves even less for renovation.
The subsidy formula makes the timing concrete. HUD calculates the number of occupied units per month across a 12-month period to set the next fiscal year's operating fund amount. Every month Young Terrace's empty units stay empty this year is money subtracted from next year's budget.
NRHA gets most of its funding from HUD, and its occupancy rate has been declining steadily since December 2022. Popkin added that the underlying problem is national: Congress has not allocated enough money to address the backlog of public housing capital needs, which HUD has estimated in the tens of billions of dollars nationwide.
The long-term answer for Young Terrace is supposed to be redevelopment. The authority first began discussing transforming the area in 2005, and the first phase of the St. Paul's area plan moved forward with the demolition of Tidewater Gardens and construction of new housing beginning in late 2020. But the redevelopment of Young Terrace and Calvert Square themselves is still years away.
That leaves the authority spending millions to repair apartments decades past their useful life that it intends to tear down and replace in the next several years, while residents remain in units with plumbing problems, mold, and unreliable heat. The vacant units wait in the same limbo: too expensive to fix for the short term, too early to demolish for the long term.
What happens in Norfolk over the next two quarters will show whether the new maintenance contracts and the $5 million authorization can move the occupancy needle before the subsidy formula locks in another reduced year. The authority's own projections, its HUD dashboard flag, and its board's tolerance for further delay all point to a hard 2027 budget conversation.
NRHA officials, including interim director Michael Clark and board chair Earl Fraley, declined to speak to WHRO for its November 9 report. The authority's next board meetings will take up the maintenance contract pipeline and the Young Terrace repair authorization against the backdrop of the HUD dashboard's red flag.
The Norfolk Redevelopment and Housing Authority says it cannot afford to renovate roughly 200 vacant units, mostly in the 1953-built Young Terrace community, WHRO reported November 9.
NRHA's occupancy rate has fallen to 87.7 percent, flagged in red on HUD's dashboard against a 96 percent target, and the authority would need to fill 163 more units to hit that target.
Because HUD's operating subsidy counts occupied units month by month over 12 months, the vacancies directly cut next year's federal funding, which the authority needs to fund the renovations.
Full unit modernization costs $50,000 to $85,000, the authority says, against $6,000 to $7,000 cosmetic turns paid under no-bid contracts that helped get the former executive director fired in November 2025.
Residents describe chronic mold, leaks and heat failures, the same deficiency categories NSPIRE treats as most serious, while the authority's redevelopment of the area remains years away.
Editorial Desk
The NSPIRE Wire Editorial Desk publishes source-verified reporting and analysis covering HUD policy, NSPIRE inspections, affordable housing finance, development, transactions, and the people shaping the industry.
Know something we should know? Have documents, corrections, or related developments on this topic? Send an editorial tip to our reporters.